New York State
Environmental Technical Working Group
E-TWG Activities
Bird and Bat Scientific Research Framework
The New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) has funded the development of a scientific research framework to guide the long-term study of potential impacts to birds and bats from offshore wind energy development in the eastern United States. This collaborative effort includes input from a range of stakeholders, including scientists, environmental nonprofits, regulators, and offshore wind energy developers.
​
NYSERDA convened a working meeting in March 2020 to inform the development of the scientific research framework. The first two days of the workshop included invited scientists from a range of sectors, including scientists, environmental nonprofits, regulators, and offshore wind energy developers. The third day of the workshop included a smaller group of subject matter experts, who used input received during the first two days to start developing the research framework. Following the workshop, experts collaborated to turn this framework into a scientific manuscript, which has been published in Frontiers in Marine Science.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Background
The Massachusetts Clean Energy Center (MassCEC) and the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) recently funded an effort to develop a scientific research framework for understanding the effects of offshore wind energy development on protected species (e.g., marine mammals and sea turtles) offshore of Massachusetts and Rhode Island. In May 2019, a group of stakeholders representing industry, academia, non-governmental organizations, and state and federal agencies recognized the utility of this framework for guiding future funding and research, and identified the need for a similar research framework focused on birds and bats. NYSERDA committed to supporting the development of a bird and bat research framework under the auspices of the Environmental Technical Working Group (E-TWG).
Goals
The scientific research framework will guide the long-term study of potential impacts to birds and bats from offshore wind energy construction and operations in the eastern United States. The goal of this framework is to help ensure that research and monitoring efforts are focused on key priorities and are appropriately designed to improve the state of knowledge. Specific objectives include:
• Identify key questions related to impacts to birds and bats associated with offshore wind construction and
operations (specifically for the east coast of the United States from Massachusetts to North Carolina),
• Develop testable hypotheses to answer key questions, including methodological considerations (taxonomic focus,
data collection, statistical power), and
• Identify data gaps and technological deficiencies that may inhibit our ability to answer these questions.
​
The framework document was developed through a series of collaborative efforts in 2020.
​
​
Stakeholder Workshop
NYSERDA convened a working meeting on March 4-6, 2020 to inform the development of the scientific research framework. The first two days of the workshop included invited experts from a range of sectors, including scientists, environmental nonprofits, regulators, and offshore wind energy developers. The third day of the workshop included a smaller group of subject matter experts, who used input received during the first two days to start developing the research framework document. View Workshop Report.
​
The workshop planning committee included representatives from NYSERDA, the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Migratory Bird Program, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Endangered Species Program, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Audubon New York, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Cornell Lab of Ornithology, and the Biodiversity Research Institute.​​​
​
Workshop Agenda
The complete workshop agenda can be found here. PDF links to workshop presentations are below.
​
Terms of Use for Presentation PDFs
​
Links to presentations from the workshop are provided below where available, courtesy of the presentation authors. These
presentation files are provided for personal edification only, and should not be cited without contacting the author(s) directly. Users should not reuse or redistribute slides, or images on these slides, without express permission from the presentation author(s).
​
Purpose and Context
​
Kate McClellan Press, NYSERDA; Kate Williams, Biodiversity Research Institute; Pat Field, Consensus Building Institute
​
Regulatory and Development Context
David Bigger, Bureau of Ocean Energy Management​
​
​
Overview of Current Knowledge
​
European Review: Seabird Displacement and Barrier Effects
Ib Krag Petersen, Aarhus University
​
European Review: Seabird and Collision Risk
Aonghais Cook, British Trust for Ornithology
​
Seabird Distribution and Abundance Data and Models for the Eastern U.S.
Arliss Winship, CSS Inc. and NOAA NCCOS
​
Seabird Movements and Finer-scale Habitat Associations in the Northwest Atlantic
Pam Loring, U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service
​
Migration of Terrestrial Birds in the Offshore Environment
Andrew Farnsworth, Cornell Lab of Ornithology
​
Trevor Peterson, Stantec
​
​
Developing Hypotheses and Identifying Study Methods
​
Overview of Data Collection Methods: Displacement, Barrier Effects, Habitat Effects
Andy Webb, HiDef Aerial Surveying
​
Existing, New, and Emerging Technologies for Measuring Collisions
Jocelyn Brown-Saracino, Department of Energy
​
Analytical and Statistical Approaches for Testing Hypotheses
Andrew Farnsworth, Cornell Lab of Ornithology​​​
​
​
Photo credits: © Kate McClellan Press; Dogfish shark © Boris Pamikov - shutterstock